More Homolka Stuff
Friday, April 28, 2000The utter folly of Homolka as victim
Christie Blatchford
National Post
ST. CATHARINES - Lest anyone forget, Karla Homolka was never actually
criminally charged in the drugging sex assault
death of her own kid sister,
Tammy, or in two separate attacks upon a young girl whose identity is protected
by a publication ban
and who is known only as "Jane Doe."
They were Homolka's freebies, as it were.
Tammy's death was tossed into the mix by senior Ontario law officers who then
believed they needed Homolka's testimony to
send her former husband, Paul
Bernardo, to jail for the rest of his life, and who were so eager to get it they
added Tammy as a
sort of prosecutorial postscript to the dishy plea bargain
they had worked out with Homolka's lawyer. The facts of the
15-year-old's
death were merely read into the record at Homolka's formal plea; this added only
two years to her sentence.
The Jane Doe assaults -- there were two because the first time, the
thoughtless Jane began to choke from the liquid veterinary
anaesthetic
Homolka was using on her, and the couple wasn't able to get 'round to attacking
her -- came to light after Homolka
was in prison, by which point the
authorities were wedded to their vision of her as a wife who had been battered
into participating
in the horrific crimes by her man.
Well, yesterday, in the same St. Catharines courthouse where, one bright July
day seven years ago the little blonde was arraigned
on two counts of
manslaughter in the murders of Leslie Mahaffy and Kristen French, the folly of
seeing Homolka as victim was
starkly before the court.
This occurred at the trial of Bernardo's first criminal lawyer, Ken Murray,
who is charged here with trying to obstruct justice for
his failure to hand
over to prosecutors six videotapes the couple made of their vicious, protracted
attacks on young girls.
The videos are under court seal, as are excruciatingly detailed
police-authored transcripts of what the tapes show, and what,
usually in
fevered whispers, Bernardo and Homolka said to one another as they took turns
degrading their victims and running the
video camera.
For much of the five-week trial, the court has tiptoed gingerly around these
tapes, with lawyers from both sides going to great
lengths to avoid even
mentioning their sordid contents.
But yesterday, Mr. Murray's lawyer, Austin Cooper, received permission from
Mr. Justice Patrick Gravely to open the sealed
transcripts and read excerpts
aloud.
Mr. Cooper was trying to show that Mr. Murray had compelling reason to deem
the tapes useful in the defence of Bernardo --
and thus justification for
holding on to them for almost 17 months -- because they reveal the Crown's star
witness to be a giddy,
lip-licking player in the crimes, a liar arguably as
fully capable of murder as her husband.
He succeeded.
But it came with a cost, as exposure to this couple always does.
Mr. Cooper had been reading for only about 25 minutes when, abruptly, he
softly pounded a fist twice on the podium before him,
shook his massive
head, and said, "May I have a moment, Your Honor?" Later, when court resumed,
Judge Gravely, in evident
distress himself, broke from routine and called an
early lunch.
In the body of the court, a small crowd, including Mr. Murray's wife, Sharon, sat stunned, some weeping, hunched in their seats.
What they heard was the vivid description of what happened on Christmas Eve
of 1990 in the rec room of the Homolka family
home in St. Catharines, after
everyone but Bernardo, Homolka and Tammy had gone to bed, and after the couple
had doped
Tammy's drinks with sleeping pills to make her drowsy.
The tapes show Homolka at her sister's head, holding a cloth onto her face, a glass bottle of dark-coloured liquid beside her.
In that bottle, on that cloth, was a drug called Halothane, which Homolka had
stolen from the animal clinic where she then worked,
this weeks before, when
Bernardo had announced he wanted to have sex with Tammy. Earlier that day, he
had decided he would
have Tammy as a "Christmas present," and Homolka
obliged.
When Tammy was rendered unconscious, Bernardo said, "Here we go! Keep 'er down!"
Later, as he was raping the pretty teenager, she stopped breathing. Tammy
died later in hospital, a death deemed accidental at the
time despite a
large, never-explained burn on her face.
The handover of her sister to Bernardo -- this at a time when he was still
living in Toronto and was merely her boyfriend, when
Homolka was living
still in the bosom of her family, working at the clinic, and hardly under his
control -- was and remains the
pivotal and defining act of the 29-year-old's
life.
The only explanation she was ever able to offer was that she thought the assault would be "a one-time thing" and felt pressured.
The only caveat she ever attempted to impose upon Bernardo -- vainly, it
turned out -- was that he wear a condom while he was
raping and sodomizing
Tammy.
A mere two weeks after Tammy's death, the soil on her grave still fresh,
Bernardo and Homolka used the dead girl's underwear
and stuffed animals as
props in grotesque sex play in her bedroom.
Because of the flickering flames of a fire in the background, and the lengthy
dialogue between the couple, this tape became known
as the "Fireside Chat"
tape at Bernardo's trial in the summer of 1995, where it was played in public.
Yesterday, Mr. Cooper read into the record virtually every word of the police
transcript -- for every 15 seconds of tape, there is a
descriptive paragraph
or two -- of that video.
Homolka is captured saying repeatedly, "I loved it when you f--- Tammy" or,
the couple's code for rape, "when you took her
virginity." Homolka uses the
couple's pet name for Bernardo's penis, "Snuffles."
At one point, he asks how she felt when he raped Tammy, and Homolka replies,
"I felt proud. I felt happy." Another time, she
says, "I never want to
forget the day you took her virginity, popped her hymen."
During this segment, in a preview of precisely what they later did in
abducting Ms. Mahaffy and Ms. French, the couple discusses
their plans for
the future -- bringing virgins as young as 13 home for Bernardo's pleasure. "We
can do it 50 more times," Homolka
says. "We can do it every weekend,
whenever we can."
"Will you help me get virgins?" he asks.
"I can go in the car with you," she replies, "if you think that's best, or stay here and clean up."
Bernardo alone abducted Ms. Mahaffy from her Burlington backyard, and after
her murder, Homolka did clean their bungalow of
evidence; Ms. French was
forced into the couple's car from a church parking lot, with Homolka holding
onto her hair from the
back seat to keep her still.
At some stage in the play-acting, the scene shifts to Tammy's bedroom,
Homolka appears wearing her dead sister's clothes -- a
little
black-and-white skirt and long-sleeved dark top -- and pretends to be Tammy.
She has with her a brown paper bag with three pairs of Tammy's underpants.
At times, both of them rub these panties on their faces, Bernardo while
staring at Tammy's graduation picture. The pair also
incorporates into the
play one of Tammy's toys, a green stuffed snake, and a red rose, which Homolka
drags lovingly across his
buttocks, saying, "We're going to Tammy tomorrow;
we're going to put it on her grave."
Homolka is shown, Mr. Cooper read out yesterday, mugging for the camera. She
also thanks Bernardo, whom she frequently
addresses by his favourite
nickname -- "The King" -- for making her sexually assault Tammy.
Bernardo notes happily at one point that "Your nipples are hard."
Mr. Cooper also read parts of the transcripts from the couple's completed assault upon Jane Doe.
This videotape was never played in open court at Bernardo's trial, so
yesterday was the first time that such details of what
happened to the girl
have been made public.
Jane, whom Homolka had met through her work at the pet clinic, was drugged --
despite the earlier close call that saw her briefly
stop breathing -- and
rendered unconscious. Homolka is again shown holding a Halothane-saturated cloth
over her mouth and
nose.
As Bernardo sticks fingers into the drugged teen, then rapes her, Homolka
frequently "waves to the camera" or "blows a kiss to
the camera," Mr. Cooper
read. At one point, "she looks at the camera, smiles, opens her mouth wide, and
wiggles her tongue wide
in a licking motion, then blows a kiss to the
camera."
She is also shown, the lawyer read, "straddling Jane's face."
Jane Doe didn't know for years that she had been violated, Bernardo's original trial heard.
I can't remember, now, if it was after the aborted assault, or the successful
one, that Jane woke up at the Bernardo-Homolka
home the next morning. What I
am certain of is that this child was ashamed. She thought she had simply had too
much to drink,
and passed out. She apologized, profusely, to her host and
hostess.
The host is in jail for life.
The hostess is slated to get out of jail in July next year, at the standard
two-thirds mark of her 12-year sentence. She will have
served not one minute
for what she did to Jane. She will never have, on her criminal record, the
ignominy of what she did to her
sister.